Agree to disagree then we can all sleep soundly tonight dreaming of becoming World Champion in the respective arts.
I was going to take issue with the use of 'combat' but then I read your sig and thought 'fair enough'
I doubt any truly serious, educated practitioners would disagree with this. I certainly don't. We have a bunch of kids running around my class and it can get a little annoying at times. Also, my instructor has TKD tunnel vision. I don't think he knows a great deal about other martial arts, but he knows a lot about TKD, and that's why I go to his class. I want to learn what I can about TKD from him and hopefully go and wreck house at the World Championships. But TKD is just a base. We're all too smart these days to think that any single art or style is sufficient to develop truly well-rounded combat skills. Great strikers get taken down and submitted, and great grapplers get sprawled and brawled. If any sarcasm's been aimed at anyone, I feel that it's been aimed at me.
I once lent my son's TKD teacher a cation joke book about martial arts. After Reading it I asked him if he enjoyed it. "I found the TKD jokes funny" was his reply. What a banker!
You should've seen the look on my instructor's face when I was having the conversation with him about MT. When I said, "If all you want to do is learn to fight, you might as well just do MT. They're good fighters," he nodded, but looked genuinely distressed. I still don't know him that well, but he seems genuinely uncomfortable when you get out of the realm of TKD.
I was told it was tantamount to child abuse to allow my son to train in muay Thai. Oh the irony when he got caught dipping a 15 year old student.
You know? He's still teaching. Got off with it as it was her word against his about whether they waited until she was 16. I think we were the only ones who left the club. The judge, in his summing up said it it was a moral decision then he'd have been guilty.
That doesn't actually surprise me. My old club seemed to try very hard to encourage a sort of cult mentality - if the coach had actually been convicted ofthat at my old club I'm fairly certain half the parents would've been convinced it was some sort of fix up.
I don't think that's unique to TKD by any means, so for now can we take this thread back on topic please folks? Feel free to start another if you want. Mitch